Lost Season 4

[MJZiggy]

But she didn't reject him, she just demanded that if he wanted to be with her, he had to want her son as well. I would want the same thing.

[twoseven]

I'm thinking that the events that led to Aaron leaving with the Six (Claire's death? how it may have happened? Locke? the Six kidnapping Aaron? Something else?) is what Jack is unwilling to deal with, Aaron obviously reminds him of this still unknown event OR Aaron possibly symbolizes a moment in which the horrible thing(s) transpired leading to or during the exodus of the Six from the island.

[twoseven]

Am I a moron for not noticing that Jack's father was in the mysterious cabin in the rocking chair, or did that slip past others as well?

Well dont forget that Jack see his pops walking around the island after they first crash so it makes sense that he would pop up like a ghost I guess.

I rembered that. It's just that I framed by framed it inside the cabin to get a good look at the figure in the chair and still didn't realize until I read elsewhere on the net that it was Jack's pop.

I went back and watched this scene again and there's almost NO WAY you can tell it's Dr. Sheppard Sr. Even knowing it's him, all you can do is faintly make out his shadowed profile and they give you a good look at his shoes. My guess is the info bubble two weeks ago when the replayed the episode told you it was him in the chair.

[oregonpackfan]

I am still perplexed about Ben and Sayid. How does Ben get off the island?

More important, why does Sayid agree to be a hitman for Ben, a real slimeball, and proceed to eliminate people on Ben's list?

[oregonpackfan]

Another question I have about Kate is how does she afford to have a house to raise the toddler Aaron? Does she marry someone who has a house or does she get money somewhere else?

[GrnBay007]

I am still perplexed about Ben and Sayid. How does Ben get off the island?

More important, why does Sayid agree to be a hitman for Ben, a real slimeball, and proceed to eliminate people on Ben's list?

My guess is that Ben has always had a way off the island ....as so he could conduct his "business" ...whatever that may be.

I hate seeing Sayid do anything Ben wants because I like Sayid....but I would have to think Ben is holding something really big over his head....like the lives of many of his island friends.

[GrnBay007]

This show really needs to be on twice a week!!

[Charles Woodson]

I am still perplexed about Ben and Sayid. How does Ben get off the island?

More important, why does Sayid agree to be a hitman for Ben, a real slimeball, and proceed to eliminate people on Ben's list?

ive been saying that i still think locke didnt blow up the submarine

[Charles Woodson]

This show really needs to be on twice a week!!

it needs to be on 24 hours a day, 7 days a week

[Charles Woodson]

I don't think it was memory loss, it was that he was psychic. I mean after all he was just naming 3 random cards.

from what i took out of it, that they were the same cards that he was trying to memorize, if so how do you explain the part where he suddenly starts crying and they ask him why hes crying and he says i dont know

[Charles Woodson]

http://mirrormattermoon.blogspot.com/

some interesting theory's.

[twoseven]

Another question I have about Kate is how does she afford to have a house to raise the toddler Aaron? Does she marry someone who has a house or does she get money somewhere else?

A large settlement with Oceanic Airlines, maybe? Sayid said to the Italian guy he ended up killing that he did nothing. When the Italian suggested you would need some money to play exclusively on the course they were on Sayid came back with the line about receiving a large settlement from the airline.

[twoseven]

Several people have suggested that Locke did not blow up the submarine. I believe it WAS destroyed. I would think that those that were in the proximity of the docks at the time might have checked on this. After all, it was not submersed, it was docked and in plain view and it would have left a pretty big mess. Nobody went to check on it at all after a massive explosion a few hundred feet away? For as strong as the writing is on this show, I would be disapointed if they would allow a fake demolition job on something as large as a sub to go on as unnoticed by inhabitants who seem to always know what's going on. Maybe it's as simple as there is another submarine, but I find it hard to believe the one we saw was not wrecked.

How does Ben get off the island, good question, to which I would add.. How did a polar bear get from the island to the other side of the globe and end up in Tunisia? How did Eco's brother's tiny plane get from central Africa to the middle of the island, again on the other side of the globe? How is an old ship, the Black Rock, landlocked in the middle of the island? Things traveling great distances unconventionally seems to be a frequent occurence on the island. If a polar bear can travel mysteriously thousands of miles to another location, why can't a human?

Ben's SECRET room had many different outfits and passports, apparently to allow him to go anywhere in the world. I would imagine his method of travel would also have to be secret, otherwise why hide all of the suits and passports from the Others? The submarine was not a secret that only Ben knew of, I think he has another way off the island that may end up being some kind of portal. Roger Alpert and Ethan Rom left the island in the submarine to recruit Juliet to the island to help with the pregnancies, other 'Others' were leaving the island, not just Ben. So again, how does a sub that was used by numerous Others that was supposedly destroyed NOT get checked on, and why the SECRET room for Ben?

[Charles Woodson]

Several people have suggested that Locke did not blow up the submarine. I believe it WAS destroyed. I would think that those that were in the proximity of the docks at the time might have checked on this. After all, it was not submersed, it was docked and in plain view and it would have left a pretty big mess. Nobody went to check on it at all after a massive explosion a few hundred feet away? For as strong as the writing is on this show, I would be disapointed if they would allow a fake demolition job on something as large as a sub to go on as unnoticed by inhabitants who seem to always know what's going on. Maybe it's as simple as there is another submarine, but I find it hard to believe the one we saw was not wrecked.

my question with it is that why would he be all wet if he really destroyed it. I think theres a chance he moved it and blew up the dock

[twoseven]

Several people have suggested that Locke did not blow up the submarine. I believe it WAS destroyed. I would think that those that were in the proximity of the docks at the time might have checked on this. After all, it was not submersed, it was docked and in plain view and it would have left a pretty big mess. Nobody went to check on it at all after a massive explosion a few hundred feet away? For as strong as the writing is on this show, I would be disapointed if they would allow a fake demolition job on something as large as a sub to go on as unnoticed by inhabitants who seem to always know what's going on. Maybe it's as simple as there is another submarine, but I find it hard to believe the one we saw was not wrecked.

my question with it is that why would he be all wet if he really destroyed it. I think theres a chance he moved it and blew up the dock

All wet because he planted the explosives on the propulsion system or another external area, he would have had to be in the water to do so.

Good call on the all wet detail. But the explosives still would have left wreckage that could have been seen the next day.