Overrated!!

[Tyrone Bigguns]

Your posts are funny. Please post some articles that state that Brady is overrated??? I'll be waiting for them and you can pm me these or post them. 4 super bowls, 5 afc championship games, 2 SB MVP's, 1 league MVP, greatest season evr by a QB and he is overrated?? Nick, your retarded and ignorant!

Your wish is my command:

http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/si_blogs/nfl/huddle_up/2006/2006/10/is-brady-overrated.html

http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/page2/story?page=gallo/080204&sportCat=nfl

http://archive.southcoasttoday.com/daily/12-04/12-23-04/b04sp475.htm

http://www.fannation.com/blogs/post/92

http://www.yardbarker.com/nfl/articles/Tom_Brady_Overrated/58685

http://ssreporters.blogspot.com/2007/06/tom-brady-overrated-qb.html

Favorite line from Gallo: I'll admit that he stunk in that playoff game against the Broncos two years ago. And that he blew our chances last year against the Colts by throwing that interception in the fourth quarter. And that he was a big zero in the Super Bowl against the Giants. He's been folding under pressure in big games for three years in a row. He's like a Manning, but with a better jaw line and two fewer Super Bowls since 2004.

[packers11]

Keep it up and I'll go off :P

were do you live??? you can't be living in the New England / Boston Area... You would be like me... A hate monger... At first, I was rooting for my home team as my (2nd favorite team) back in 01... But if you just started to hear these fans... They are worse than bear fans / bearman... Its sickening...

[b bulldog]

The first article is the only one with credibility and he even stated that he has a ton of talent but the hype has gone too far, I can actually agree with that. The other articles and what???

Look up some of the stuff written by NFL insiders, people that actually know the game.

[b bulldog]

Do you want me to find the peopkle who see it my way Tyrone because I've just done a quick search and we can both post our references and I bet mine more than rump yours. my quick search had people from John Madden, Jimmy Johnson, ESPN senior NFL writer, CBS Sportsline senior writer, Mike Martz,Marv levy, Art Rooney Jr, Ken Meyer, Dick Haley, Larry kennan, and James Harris have him third behind Graham and Montana ect. I think I'll rest my case.

[Tyrone Bigguns]

The first article is the only one with credibility and he even stated that he has a ton of talent but the hype has gone too far, I can actually agree with that. The other articles and what???

Look up some of the stuff written by NFL insiders, people that actually know the game.

You asked for articles that said he was overrated. I provided you them. Now you want to question their credibility? Ok.

But, that wasnt' your criteria. More to the point..who are you to question credibilty. Gallo writes for espn, one guy writes for a paper, etc.

Of course, there will be more. It is early. A season or two more and reevaluation will happen.

Your credibility is lacking. i"m stil waiting for scouts and recruiters as we discussed in the badger forum. Last post you had was from a WRITER (fiutak)..not a scout or recruiter.

[b bulldog]

Ahh I think Scout.com has talent evaluaters working for them that would fit your criteria and that is just off the top of my head.

[b bulldog]

Same with rival;s.com

[b bulldog]

Mike Farrell head recruiting guru for Rivals.com has him as his best and has him deciding between the Nitney Lions and the BUcks now.

[b bulldog]

Parade magazines national player of the year

[b bulldog]

Jim Tressel," 18 is great but the 19th would be the cherry"

[Tyrone Bigguns]

I believe the term was "can't miss"...i'll be waiting for ANY source that says he can't miss.

[Zool]

I'm still waiting to hear how guys who guess at their jobs are "credible" or "experts". I could throw shit against the wall and see what sticks too. Sign me up. Of the supposed cant miss prospects, how many have missed? I'm going to guess 50%.

Prospect A from a small school in Alabama had 1800 yards in his senior season and 1500 in his junior season. Prospect B from a small school in Texas had 1800 yards in his senior season and 1500 in his junior season. Both of these guys have the potential to be big time contributors to their respective teams.

Where's my check?

[pbmax]

EDIT: Cripes, I've got to stop jumping threads. I'm with KYPack. Noodle wins this thread.

Patler, I think you have been reading too much Harv and Justin. Brady has 3 Super Bowl wins and a MVP. He also owns the best single passing season in the post 1978 era. He is clearly above Aikman and close to Montana.

He won with mediocre pass catchers and then scored the go ahead TD in another Super Bowl in the 4th quarter with the best set of WRs in the league that season. He has done it every way except the Dilfer way.

Aikman was never this dominant and had a top five running game to complement him.

Brady teams in the first three Super Bowls were a notch below the Packers in 95-96-97. The 2007 Pats were better than all the Packer teams Favre has been on with the exception of the 96 team, a game I would love to see.

Wonder how people will rank him if it continues, and he never wins another title. I'd have to think closer to the Aikman class than the Montana class.

I suspect that is about right.

[pbmax]

Tyrone, I love your posts. But even you can't sneak a DJ Gallo article into a serious post without raising a red flag. DJ isn't taking this seriously, and neither should we.

Your posts are funny. Please post some articles that state that Brady is overrated??? I'll be waiting for them and you can pm me these or post them. 4 super bowls, 5 afc championship games, 2 SB MVP's, 1 league MVP, greatest season evr by a QB and he is overrated?? Nick, your retarded and ignorant!

Your wish is my command:
....

http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/page2/story?page=gallo/080204&sportCat=nfl

....

Favorite line from Gallo: I'll admit that he stunk in that playoff game against the Broncos two years ago. And that he blew our chances last year against the Colts by throwing that interception in the fourth quarter. And that he was a big zero in the Super Bowl against the Giants. He's been folding under pressure in big games for three years in a row. He's like a Manning, but with a better jaw line and two fewer Super Bowls since 2004.

[mission]

I wonder what score bulldog would get on his wonderlic?



wait. I'm not wondering anymore. hopefully for his sake, he's an alcoholic and can use that as an excuse