Why Rodgers Will Fail and Why Favre Needs to Come Back

[Scott Campbell]

Tank,

I think Bill Schroeder is a better pro WR than Jordy Nelson and you can't prove me wrong. Get the point?

I see your Bill Schroeder, and raise you a Michael Huff.

[Tankduke]

Many no skills qbs have been drafted higher than Rodgers in the past. Tim Couch, Akili Smith, Ryan Leaf, to name a few.

.......Joey Harrington......

Harrington is a guy who has the skills in the world but has always been cursed with supporting casts that aren't worth a shitload.

Put Harrington on the current Packer, plus Moss (shouldve been a Packer but you know the definition of Thompson), and he'll lead the Pack to a SB victory (plus 3 or 4 more).

[Scott Campbell]

Put Harrington on the current Packer,........

Excellent idea Tank, but I doubt he could be pried away from his current team.


And you say Rodgers has a weak arm?

[Tankduke]

The guy is a bit above Brooks Bollinger when it comes to arm strength.

Jennings contends he throws it a bit harder than Favre.

Jennings was just being nice to ARod. What was he supposed to say? Rodgers lacks arm strength (or he has a so and so arm), and then face the possibility of not having another pass thrown his way again, not even when he's as open as the infinite universe?

[Scott Campbell]

The guy is a bit above Brooks Bollinger when it comes to arm strength.

Jennings contends he throws it a bit harder than Favre.

Jennings was just being nice to ARod. What was he supposed to say?

He didn't have to say anything at all Tank. And can someone with what you perceive to be Rodgers marginal talent really afford to not throw to someone as talented as Jennings anyway? Regardless of what he says?

[Tankduke]

All talk and no action.

Well, you do realize he's been asked by the Packers to carry a clipboard for 3 years. How much action were you expecting?

I think many players would have squawked a lot more about riding the pine for that long. Aaron stayed pretty quiet.

Do you realize that Rodgers has been injured more than the guy named Injury Prone?

If Rodgers were holding the clipboard for a HS or College team, then he can complain all he wants. But we're talking about the NFL. This guy is getting paid 7 or 8 figures just to hold a clipboard, so he needs to stfu and let a the better qb play (favre).

[Scott Campbell]

Do you realize that Rodgers has been injured more than the guy named Injury Prone?

Did I ever say he wasn't?

[Scott Campbell]

.........so he needs to stfu and let a the better qb play (favre).

I thought you just complained about his lack of action? Make up your mind. Do you want him to stfu, or do you want action?

[Tankduke]

Tank,

I think Bill Schroeder is a better pro WR than Jordy Nelson and you can't prove me wrong. Get the point?

Schroeder was 6'4" and ran the 40 in 4.3 seconds. Nelson is 6'3" and runs the 40 in 4.6 seconds. I'll take Schroeder in his prime over Nelson any day.

[Tankduke]

.........so he needs to stfu and let a the better qb play (favre).

I thought you just complained about his lack of action? Make up your mind. Do you want him to stfu, or do you want action?

On a second thought, I guess its better to have Arod act than stfu up. Rodgers needs to kiss Favre's ass and go tell that incompetent whore of a Polar Bear that Favre gives the Packers there best shot at winning the SB, and therefore thompson needs to either resign or reinsert favre as starting qb.

[Scott Campbell]

Schroeder was 6'4" and ran the 40 in 4.3 seconds. Nelson is 6'3" and runs the 40 in 4.6 seconds.

By that logic we should be giving Jerry Rice's Hall of Fame slot to Willie Gault.

[Tankduke]

Schroeder was 6'4" and ran the 40 in 4.3 seconds. Nelson is 6'3" and runs the 40 in 4.6 seconds.

By that logic we should be giving Jerry Rice's Hall of Fame slot to Willie Gault.

No one is saying Schroeder should be in the NFL HOF.

[Scott Campbell]

Schroeder was 6'4" and ran the 40 in 4.3 seconds. Nelson is 6'3" and runs the 40 in 4.6 seconds.

By that logic we should be giving Jerry Rice's Hall of Fame slot to Willie Gault.

No one is saying Schroeder should be in the NFL HOF.

But you are assuming Shroeder is better than Nelson based on 2 of the most rudimentary combine numbers.

[Tankduke]

Schroeder was 6'4" and ran the 40 in 4.3 seconds. Nelson is 6'3" and runs the 40 in 4.6 seconds.

By that logic we should be giving Jerry Rice's Hall of Fame slot to Willie Gault.

No one is saying Schroeder should be in the NFL HOF.

But you are assuming Shroeder is better than Nelson based on 2 of the most rudimentary combine numbers.

Schroeder is better than Nelson. Time will prove me right.

[Scott Campbell]

Schroeder is better than Nelson. Time will prove me right.

You better hope time is kinder to you on this one than it was on all the others.