Greg Jennings, top tier WR?

[bobblehead]

Since everyone keeps talking about "top tier" and "second tier," will someone please explain how many wide receivers are in a "tier"???

8

[MadtownPacker]

With his age and his personality/work ethic, there is no other WR in the league I would trade him for.

Andre Johnson would be a push.

I would take Larry Fitzgerald over him any day. The catches he made against the Boys were incredible.

Fitzgerald made a great catch but Greg "the big play" Jennings makes great plays. Have to go with #85 if you need a TD and you need it now. Give him the $$$ now!!

[Partial]

I would take...

Calvin Johnson
TO
Randy Moss
Larry Fitz

over him

[Fritz]

[quote="bobblehead"]

Since everyone keeps talking about "top tier" and "second tier," will someone please explain how many wide receivers are in a "tier"???

8[/quote


Thank you, Bobble head. If a tier is 8, then hell yes Jennings is top tier.

Name eight wide receivers who are better than Jennings.

Owens? Moss? Fitzgerald? Johnson?

Who else?

[Tyrone Bigguns]

With his age and his personality/work ethic, there is no other WR in the league I would trade him for.

Andre Johnson would be a push.

I would take Larry Fitzgerald over him any day. The catches he made against the Boys were incredible.

As good as he has been, Jennings isn't 6'3" tall and that will keep him just a tad under the top guys. What he does he does well, but ty is right...he is no Fitzgerald.

I know that must have killed you to write that.

There are a number of receivers that i would take over jennings. That doesnt' mean i don't like him. I put these guys here based on talent.

Q...big, tough, great blocker, fearless.

Fitz...his game speaks for itself.

Ocho

Steve Smith...a one man wrecking crew.

Colston

Andre johnson

Plax...all he does is produce. Wasn't able to practice last year and look at how he played in games.

Randy Moss..yes, he has had a bad attitude, but not last year...and, he demands double coverage.

Reggie Wayne/Marvin Harrison

Welker...prolly a tie, but he may be the best slot receiver in the league. Plus, he is white!!!

There are a number of receivers that I would put in the same cat as Jennings:

Coles
S. moss
Reggie Brown
Brandon Marshall
Housh
Roddy White
Dwayne Bowe
Lee Evans

[Bossman641]

With his age and his personality/work ethic, there is no other WR in the league I would trade him for.

Andre Johnson would be a push.

I would take Larry Fitzgerald over him any day. The catches he made against the Boys were incredible.

As good as he has been, Jennings isn't 6'3" tall and that will keep him just a tad under the top guys. What he does he does well, but ty is right...he is no Fitzgerald.

I know that must have killed you to write that.

There are a number of receivers that i would take over jennings. That doesnt' mean i don't like him. I put these guys here based on talent.

Q...big, tough, great blocker, fearless.

Fitz...his game speaks for itself.

Ocho

Steve Smith...a one man wrecking crew.

Colston

Andre johnson

Plax...all he does is produce. Wasn't able to practice last year and look at how he played in games.

Randy Moss..yes, he has had a bad attitude, but not last year...and, he demands double coverage.

Reggie Wayne/Marvin Harrison

Welker...prolly a tie, but he may be the best slot receiver in the league. Plus, he is white!!!

There are a number of receivers that I would put in the same cat as Jennings:

Coles
S. moss
Reggie Brown
Brandon Marshall
Housh
Roddy White
Dwayne Bowe
Lee Evans

Reggie Brown? You can't be for real

[The Shadow]

Absolutely a top tier receiver at this point.
And there's still an upside.

[The Shadow]

I would take...

Calvin Johnson
TO
Randy Moss
Larry Fitz

over him

Or any other wide receiver NOT drafted by Ted Thompson, right?
(You forgot Bobby Engram, Marty Booker, Bobby Wade, etc.)

[Tyrone Bigguns]

Bossman,

Brown has been injured...but, he has 10 catches for 163 yards...that is in 2 games.

I coulda added others. Have you looked at Bruce's numbers. Considering who is tossing him the ball...19 yard average and 5 tds.

Should i put DeSean Jackson up as well. Or Kevin Curtis.

[falco]

wow ty, you're so off base on this one its not funny

[Packers4Ever]

I don't care how he ranks against any of the other receivers. What I care about is that he keeps catching those bombs and scoring touchdowns on startled opponents. He always seems to get those when we really need a spark. I think when it's all said and done, he will compare favorable with any one else in the league.

Agreed, he was an eyecatcher from Day 1

and still has a great career ahead of him.

[Tyrone Bigguns]

wow ty, you're so off base on this one its not funny

Right. Based on what...like his increased production every year. His 61 catches last year. That he has never had less than 40 catches a year.

I didnt' say he was better. I said he is in the same tier.

[Bossman641]

Bossman,

Brown has been injured...but, he has 10 catches for 163 yards...that is in 2 games.

I coulda added others. Have you looked at Bruce's numbers. Considering who is tossing him the ball...19 yard average and 5 tds.

Should i put DeSean Jackson up as well. Or Kevin Curtis.

Reggie Brown hasn't been a top or even second tier WR. Isaac Bruce? He of 303 yards and 4 TD's? He was a top WR about 8 years ago.

Let's get serious Ty.

[packers11]

Jennings leads the league in yards with 653...

the next 4 behind him are

Roddy White - 566
Larry Fitz - 546
Marshall - 521
Witten - 497


TY stop posting without actually doing some research... You make yourself look like a complete moron...

[HarveyWallbangers]

Reggie Brown hasn't been a top or even second tier WR. Isaac Bruce? He of 303 yards and 4 TD's? He was a top WR about 8 years ago.

Let's get serious Ty.

It's pretty laughable. He started off pretty good, but it went downhill as the post got longer.