Chad Pennington: MVP?

[Pacopete4]

Well, Pennington just threw his 3rd pick. Guess he's washed up too!

I thought you were above all this....

she was making a joke.. get over it

[Lurker64]

she was making a joke.. get over it

So, in the interest of fairness, are we allowed to make jokes that are somewhat critical of Favre and still remain "above the fray"?

[Partial]

Vince...

[Bossman641]

Well, Pennington just threw his 3rd pick. Guess he's washed up too!

I thought you were above all this....

she was making a joke.. get over it

Isn't that what half the shit in the Favre thread is?

[Bossman641]

she was making a joke.. get over it

So, in the interest of fairness, are we allowed to make jokes that are somewhat critical of Favre and still remain "above the fray"?

You can only make jokes backing Favre, not against him. If you make jokes against Favre you are a trouble-maker. Mad really needs to put a sticky up about this.

[Partial]

My God. Cut the shit. 007 is a vet around here..

[Zool]

My God. Cut the shit. 007 is a vet around here..

Cant have it both ways P. Either everyone is fair game or no one is.

[GrnBay007]

she was making a joke.. get over it

So, in the interest of fairness, are we allowed to make jokes that are somewhat critical of Favre and still remain "above the fray"?

You can only make jokes backing Favre, not against him. If you make jokes against Favre you are a trouble-maker. Mad really needs to put a sticky up about this.

Sorry, I didn't really see any "jokes". Most of what I saw was very mean-hearted comments about someone that gave the Packers many winning seasons. Guess I'm just a bit more sentimental then most of you. I have that ability to show respect for the past.

What does Pennington mean to me? NADA. If what Favre did for the Green Bay Packers means nothing to you, carry on. Have at it.

[Bretsky]

ED REED is a man among boyz

4 picks and counting

[packinpatland]

#4.................................

[Bossman641]

My God. Cut the shit. 007 is a vet around here..

I understand. I'm not singling her out. Many people have spent all season propping up Favre, tearing down TT, and generally gloating over Favre and the Jets.

Now, for the past 5 weeks, they have wanted to silence the "Favre-haters" and just drop the whole argument. Anyone who wants to talk about Favre NOW is considered to be someone who is obsessed with Favre and holding on to the past. Where was that the first 12 weeks of the season? It just seems a bit hypocritical to me.

I personally have no problem with it either way. You know what you get when you look in the Favre thread.

Paco and I don't see eye-to-eye on almost anything. I still like seeing his point of view. If I don't feel like it is worth it to try and tell him how I think he is wrong I simply skip his posts. Nothing wrong with that.

[packers11]

Thomas Jones... Do you want to comment on your former teammate?

[Partial]

My God. Cut the shit. 007 is a vet around here..

I understand. I'm not singling her out. Many people have spent all season propping up Favre, tearing down TT, and generally gloating over Favre and the Jets.

Now, for the past 5 weeks, they have wanted to silence the "Favre-haters" and just drop the whole argument. Anyone who wants to talk about Favre NOW is considered to be someone who is obsessed with Favre and holding on to the past. Where was that the first 12 weeks of the season? It just seems a bit hypocritical to me.

I personally have no problem with it either way. You know what you get when you look in the Favre thread.

Paco and I don't see eye-to-eye on almost anything. I still like seeing his point of view. If I don't feel like it is worth it to try and tell him how I think he is wrong I simply skip his posts. Nothing wrong with that.

Then take it to PM. I don't give a shit. I'm cleaning this joint up. Get on the train or get out of the way.

[Bossman641]

My God. Cut the shit. 007 is a vet around here..

I understand. I'm not singling her out. Many people have spent all season propping up Favre, tearing down TT, and generally gloating over Favre and the Jets.

Now, for the past 5 weeks, they have wanted to silence the "Favre-haters" and just drop the whole argument. Anyone who wants to talk about Favre NOW is considered to be someone who is obsessed with Favre and holding on to the past. Where was that the first 12 weeks of the season? It just seems a bit hypocritical to me.

I personally have no problem with it either way. You know what you get when you look in the Favre thread.

Paco and I don't see eye-to-eye on almost anything. I still like seeing his point of view. If I don't feel like it is worth it to try and tell him how I think he is wrong I simply skip his posts. Nothing wrong with that.

Then take it to PM. I don't give a shit. I'm cleaning this joint up. Get on the train or get out of the way.

Are you kidding me?

I guess the next time there is a topic about Rodgers and you disagree with someone I should expect not to see any of your posts in there right? Cause you'll have just PM'ed posters instead?

[Bretsky]

My God. Cut the shit. 007 is a vet around here..

I understand. I'm not singling her out. Many people have spent all season propping up Favre, tearing down TT, and generally gloating over Favre and the Jets.

Now, for the past 5 weeks, they have wanted to silence the "Favre-haters" and just drop the whole argument. Anyone who wants to talk about Favre NOW is considered to be someone who is obsessed with Favre and holding on to the past. Where was that the first 12 weeks of the season? It just seems a bit hypocritical to me.

I personally have no problem with it either way. You know what you get when you look in the Favre thread.

Paco and I don't see eye-to-eye on almost anything. I still like seeing his point of view. If I don't feel like it is worth it to try and tell him how I think he is wrong I simply skip his posts. Nothing wrong with that.

I'm not sure there are that many

The gloaters might be paco, mobb, and maybe gex at times
The other extremists who do the same thing but on the anti side may be led by cpk and probably shadow

And then there is a load of people who lean one way, still read, and get irked by some comments.

Overall not that many when you consider how many posters we have. I browsed over a couple other forums yesterday and one was 5x as bad as this one in terms of Favre threads and the other was about the same.