McCarthy ranked 16th

[Joemailman]

This is an important year for McCarthy. I thought he had an off year last year. There were times where he seemed to get conservative in the 4th quarter and took the ball out of Arod's hands. He seemed to coach as if the defense was the strength of the team, which it clearly was not, especially after losing Jenkins and Barnett. I also thought he was rather stubborn about how he distributed carries among the running backs, continuing to give Grant the bulk of the carries even when he was ineffective.

With won/loss records of 8-8, 13-3 and 6-10, it's hard to get a handle on how effective he is. This season should tell us a lot.

[pbmax]

I don't think the 16th best coach by reputation lands Capers to coordinate the D. Nor does he get Trgovac or Perry.

This list, at first glance, seems to be the teams record over the last two, three or four years. And how can you be the worst coaches (Morris and McDaniels) when you have never been the head coach?

[Tyrone Bigguns]

.sheepshead wrote:
Since when?


Partial gave his opinion. Why try an start shit?? DO you have an opinion on the matter or is your only priority to start an argument??
_________________
Look with hope to the horizon of today, for today is all we truly have.

who in the fuck asked you?

Thought it was a public forum...

NO FUCKING SHIT DICKHEAD. SO SOMEHOW I CANT QUESTION A GUYS OPINION? WHAT PLANET ARE YOU FROM?

"When you get personal you know you have won." said Sheepshead numerous times.

[Tyrone Bigguns]

I don't think the 16th best coach by reputation lands Capers to coordinate the D. Nor does he get Trgovac or Perry.

This list, at first glance, seems to be the teams record over the last two, three or four years. And how can you be the worst coaches (Morris and McDaniels) when you have never been the head coach?

Those who have experience, even poor record wise, have more wins than those 2. Therefore they are the worst.

[Oscar]

.sheepshead wrote:
Since when?


Partial gave his opinion. Why try an start shit?? DO you have an opinion on the matter or is your only priority to start an argument??
_________________
Look with hope to the horizon of today, for today is all we truly have.

who in the fuck asked you?

Thought it was a public forum...

NO FUCKING SHIT DICKHEAD. SO SOMEHOW I CANT QUESTION A GUYS OPINION? WHAT PLANET ARE YOU FROM?

Still a public forum..

[sheepshead]

way out of line sheepshead

How so? I really do have a point here. Jeffro doesnt seem to think these forums are meant to challenge another's opinion. He injected himself into the conversation and he started with the foul language. If I ever get an answer from partial(i'm not holding my breath) I 'll make my point.

[Oscar]

I thought P said he thought M.M. T.T. were both good at there jobs..

[Oscar]

No mood to argue... Night all..

[sheepshead]

If he answers me, ill make my point-again, im not sure what you acting as a cop accomplishes. It's actually YOU that started the "shit" as you put it.

[Oscar]

If he answers me, ill make my point-again, im not sure what you acting as a cop accomplishes. It's actually YOU that started the "shit" as you put it.

Sorry lil buddy. I'll be a lil more careful with my foul language.. Night all...

[Bretsky]

way out of line sheepshead

[Partial]

Since when?

Since always? What are you implying here?

I agree with sheepshead. My impression was that TT was average in your eyes and a complete idiot for getting rid of Favre.

One move doesn't make a GM. I don't like the move. It worked out ok. It was bound to happen eventually, via Brett leaving or whatever. For what its worth, I don't think they're treating Tauscher much better this year. At least offer the guy a camp contract and let him use Packer facilities to rehab and to be with his teammates. He's a leader and a veteran, and according to LeRoy Butler and Gary Ellerson he's the offensive linemen vocal leader.

My opinion of TT is that if he doesn't improve his drafting (prior to this year), he needs to address some positions via FA. I really like this years draft outside of Raji. Would have preferred Crabtree as I believe he was BPA, but I'm still hopeful that Raji becomes a hoss.

I'm not super hot or super cold on him, and I think his team has a long way to go from being great, but he has shown that he understands the core principals of building a team imo.

[The Leaper]

I think he is better than #16...but not by a longshot. I'd stick him around #12...but I would also include the coaches who don't have a coaching job at the moment, such as Cowher and Dungy.

Coaches who I think are DEFINITELY better than McCarthy:

Beli
Cowher
Dungy
Coughlin
Reid
Fisher

Coaches who I think are PROBABLY better:

Tomlin
Lovie
Mike Smith
Harbaugh
Gruden

[Joemailman]

Since when?

Since always? What are you implying here?

I agree with sheepshead. My impression was that TT was average in your eyes and a complete idiot for getting rid of Favre.

One move doesn't make a GM. I don't like the move. It worked out ok. It was bound to happen eventually, via Brett leaving or whatever. For what its worth, I don't think they're treating Tauscher much better this year. At least offer the guy a camp contract and let him use Packer facilities to rehab and to be with his teammates. He's a leader and a veteran, and according to LeRoy Butler and Gary Ellerson he's the offensive linemen vocal leader.

My opinion of TT is that if he doesn't improve his drafting (prior to this year), he needs to address some positions via FA. I really like this years draft outside of Raji. Would have preferred Crabtree as I believe he was BPA, but I'm still hopeful that Raji becomes a hoss.

I'm not super hot or super cold on him, and I think his team has a long way to go from being great, but he has shown that he understands the core principals of building a team imo.

I'm ok with how they are treating Tauscher. 1 of 3 things will happen with Tauscher:

1. He recovers from his injury and signs with the Packers.
2. He recovers from his injury and signs with another team.
3. he can't recover and announces his retirement.

I think any of those scenarios would be better than signing Tauscher to a minimum contract and then cutting him if he can't make it. I think the Packers would rather avoid that.

[pbmax]

Since when?

Since always? What are you implying here?

I agree with sheepshead. My impression was that TT was average in your eyes and a complete idiot for getting rid of Favre.

One move doesn't make a GM. I don't like the move. It worked out ok. It was bound to happen eventually, via Brett leaving or whatever. For what its worth, I don't think they're treating Tauscher much better this year. At least offer the guy a camp contract and let him use Packer facilities to rehab and to be with his teammates. He's a leader and a veteran, and according to LeRoy Butler and Gary Ellerson he's the offensive linemen vocal leader.

My opinion of TT is that if he doesn't improve his drafting (prior to this year), he needs to address some positions via FA. I really like this years draft outside of Raji. Would have preferred Crabtree as I believe he was BPA, but I'm still hopeful that Raji becomes a hoss.

I'm not super hot or super cold on him, and I think his team has a long way to go from being great, but he has shown that he understands the core principals of building a team imo.

He has been using the Packer facilities according to the man himself on Milwaukee radio.