Who would you trade Rodgers for?

[falco]

Just curious.

Not just for one year, but the long term success of the franchise.

[PaCkFan_n_MD]

Matt Ryan

[Tyrone Bigguns]

Multiple players. John Hadl like deal.

[BallHawk]

Adrian Peterson.

And that's about it.

[Rastak]

As a Viking fan Tarvaris Jackson.....


In the spirit of the thread a real answer.....


Not too many from what I have seen.


Matt Ryan
maybe Ben Rothlesberger
Tom Brady
Drew Brees
maybe Joe Flacco

[falco]

As a Viking fan Tarvaris Jackson.....


In the spirit of the thread a real answer.....


Not too many from what I have seen.


Matt Ryan
maybe Ben Rothlesberger
Tom Brady
Drew Brees
maybe Joe Flacco

I wondered about Brady... clearly he is arguably the best there is right now, but is he old enough that it would not be worth building a franchise around him anymore?

Same might go for Brees - I think he is better than Rodgers, but is Rodgers youth provide enough of an upside to stick with him?

I haven't seen enough of Matt Ryan to say.

[falco]

Adrian Peterson.

And that's about it.

Interesting answer.. I was thinking about QBs, but you make a good point.

My concern would be that the lifespan of a RB is typically much shorter than that of a QB. Would we get more mileage out of Rodgers than Peterson?

[falco]

Some might argue Phillip Rivers, but I don't care for his attitude/immaturity.

I think Rodgers has some good intangible leadership skills.

[Partial]

Adrian Peterson
Patrick Willis
Mario Williams
Matt Ryan

[Brando19]

Adrian Peterson
Maybe Michael Turner
Mario Williams
If we didn't have Jennings...maybe Fitzgerald.

[Rastak]

I probably wouldn't trade him for anything but another QB.....maybe Peterson being the only exception.

[mmmdk]

I'd trade Rodgers for season tickets at Lambeau

[BallHawk]

I probably wouldn't trade him for anything but another QB.....maybe Peterson being the only exception.

Peterson being the best player in the NFL, I'd find it hard not to trade any player for him. Aside from him, there isn't a single player I'd trade Aaron for. Matt Ryan is still young. Tom Brady and Drew Brees are getting older. Rivers isn't the shining example of a guy I'd want on my team....and who said Joe Flacco? WTF?

[crosbiegrad]

I agree with what has been said above about Peterson. He's easily the league's best player and I'd trade Rodgers for him in a heartbeat but Joe Flacco?!!!! I'd be pissed if Thompson traded Rodgers for Flacco

[oregonpackfan]

With the time investment the Packers have had in Rodgers, 3 years on the bench behind Favre, last year, and now this year, Rodgers is untradable--period!