Coach of the Year

[Tony Oday]

Well lets say this. With the losses in personnel this year, AR getting banged around, ST sucking ass...what if MM brings us to the promised land and gets that shiny new trophy that is the same as the other three we have? Is he on the level of the Walrus then? is TT better than Wolf? Is AR...well we all know he will be better than Favre, it will be the Montana Young Conversation all over!

[MJZiggy]

Well lets say this. With the losses in personnel this year, AR getting banged around, ST sucking ass...what if MM brings us to the promised land and gets that shiny new trophy that is the same as the other three we have? Is he on the level of the Walrus then? is TT better than Wolf? Is AR...well we all know he will be better than Favre, it will be the Montana Young Conversation all over!

I, for one, would like to have that conversation.

[billy_oliver880]

Haley should get it....

[vince]

Haley should get it....

Yeah, I think he'd get my vote too.

[Freak Out]

KC has built a he'll of a team.

[Freak Out]

Damn auto correct......and Bossman.....that avatar is driving me CRAZY!

[hoosier]

I'm just not so enamored, but I'll wait for 2011 before bringing up the "too creative" label again. But when we're healthy, and the "creative genius" goes with a low percentage toss to try and win the game, I'm headed for GB to hit him with my car, and then I'm telling all you experts that "I told you so".

Did you complain after the Packers beat Chicago in the 2009 opener, when Rodgers hit Jennings on a 3rd and 1 bomb from midfield with less than 2 minutes to go and trailing by 5?

[mraynrand]

Did you complain after the Packers beat Chicago in the 2009 opener, when Rodgers hit Jennings on a 3rd and 1 bomb from midfield with less than 2 minutes to go and trailing by 5?

Without knowing for sure, I'd bet good money that he did.

[Bretsky]

H squred are both deserving.........Haley and Hoody

[gex]

Haley should get it....

3rd'd

[get louder at lambeau]

Hes a poor man's Andy Reid IMO, without the fucked up sons.

That's so sweet. I'm gonna cry.

[Tarlam!]

Well, the Team of the Year wins the Superbowl - even the 18-0 Pats lost the most important game due to solid coaching and solid playby the Giants. Usually teams peaking at the right time are that team, no matter how they start out. Steelers as Wildcards anyone?

But if there was an award for Organization of the Year, I give it to the 2010 Pack. Overcoming some devastating injuries means the scouts had to scout well, TT had to pull the trigger, Murphy had to keep upbeat, the coaches had to coach well, players needed to commit and play well with a few unsung heros needing to turn into stars snd sbove all, the fans needed to give the team love.

On the latter, I'll never forget the positive vibes around here despite the loss to the dirty birds.

From top to bottom, the GBP have their sheet together.

[vince]

Detroit 7 Packers 3

How about we play a little game mmmdk. Let's figure out the big picture together about whether McCarthy is a good coach or bad coach. You list a game McCarthy did a bad job, like you did above, and I'll list a game McCarthy did a good or great job and let's see who runs out of games first OK?

Packers 45 Giants 17

Your turn.

[Fritz]

Not that easy, Vince. I wish it were. What'll happen is that the anti-MMers will begin to argue that certain wins were despite MM and thus were poorly coached.

[vince]

You mean they won because of the talent that MM developed and coached up?