ARE WE GIVING AROD A FREE PASS ??????????????????

[mraynrand]

Your really one strange fella.

This is a Green Bay Packer Forum.

Here comes the lecture

[woodbuck27]

Here comes the lecture

A wise man once said:

Regarding people beyond a certain pre adult age. You can't teach common sense.

[smuggler]

Some of you guys will be saying that Aaron Rodgers is better than Tom Brady.

If that's the case you better hope that MM grows a lot in this off season. Aaron's now three Super Bowl wins away.

Ah, the rings argument. Nope. I love championships as much as the next guy, but in no plane of existence is Eli Manning a better quarterback than Fran Tarkenton.

Brady is not as good as Rodgers currently. Brady at his peak, that's debatable. He played well in the game today, but could just as easily have been a goat.

[mraynrand]

A wise man once said:

Regarding people beyond a certain pre adult age. You can't teach common sense.

to thine own self be true!

[woodbuck27]

Ah, the rings argument. Nope. I love championships as much as the next guy, but in no plane of existence is Eli Manning a better quarterback than Fran Tarkenton.

Brady is not as good as Rodgers currently. Brady at his peak, that's debatable. He played well in the game today, but could just as easily have been a goat.

That was a good Super Bowl game. Tom Brady was that games MVP.

Like most great matchup's it comes down to one play.

Last night and today Tom Brady and Patriot Nation is grateful to Malcolm Butler.

[ThunderDan]

The next thing:

Some of you guys will be saying that Aaron Rodgers is better than Tom Brady.

If that's the case you better hope that MM grows a lot in this off season. Aaron's now three Super Bowl wins away.

Congratulations Aaron Rodgers on your second NFL MVP Award.

You deserved it hands down.

So which statement is true? If Aaron deserved the award hands down how can Tom Brady be better?

[woodbuck27]

So which statement is true? If Aaron deserved the award hands down how can Tom Brady be better?

Both statements have merit.

[denverYooper]

Ah, the rings argument. Nope. I love championships as much as the next guy, but in no plane of existence is Eli Manning a better quarterback than Fran Tarkenton.

Brady is not as good as Rodgers currently. Brady at his peak, that's debatable. He played well in the game today, but could just as easily have been a goat.

Yeah, it's funny. He threw a pick in the endzone to end their first drive and another INT that gave Seattle the lead. That second INT really looked like it could have been the turning point for a while.

[Teamcheez1]

So which statement is true? If Aaron deserved the award hands down how can Tom Brady be better?

Tom Brady has had a spectacular career, no doubt about that.

Today, a healthy AR is hands down better than Brady.

[woodbuck27]

Tom Brady has had a spectacular career, no doubt about that.

Today, a healthy AR is hands down better than Brady.

Sure ... sure.

Tom Brady was MVP (3× Super Bowl MVP (XXXVI, XXXVIII, XLIX) and won his 4th Super Bowl Ring yesterday.

[denverYooper]

I have your new avatar Woody:

[Pugger]

Ah, the rings argument. Nope. I love championships as much as the next guy, but in no plane of existence is Eli Manning a better quarterback than Fran Tarkenton.

Brady is not as good as Rodgers currently. Brady at his peak, that's debatable. He played well in the game today, but could just as easily have been a goat.

Yes, had Seattle scored and Wilson not thrown that pick everyone would be dissecting Brady's two INTs in that Super Bowl. Right now I'd take Rodgers and his skill set over Brady all day long.

[woodbuck27]

I have your new avatar Woody:

Thanks for being astute .

That's how I imagine I'll look in heaven. Young and sweet.

[PaCkFan_n_MD]

Tom Brady has had a spectacular career, no doubt about that.

Today, a healthy AR is hands down better than Brady.

Hands down?? Are you kidding?? Brady is better than Rodgers, period. More to being a great qb than throwing a nice ball. Brady is as clutch as it gets.. Four game winning drives in the SuperBowl..

The defense basically gift wrapped a packers win against Seattle and he couldn't even sustain a drive less enough come from behind by ten points. No one in their right mind would put rodgers over Brady. Not just all time but right now.

[Bossman641]

Call me a homer but I'll take a healthy Rodgers over the current Brady. Brady really struggles with pressure in his face (the end zone pick was horrific) and can't escape like Rodgers can. What was the stat they said last night, Brady was something like 1/23 on passes >20+ yards in his SB career? You can't only compare the NFCCG vs the SB. Brady had the benefit of health, a neutral site, and a Seattle defense missing their nickelback for almost the entire game and Avril for the majority of the second half.