Rodgers 2020 MVP campaign!

[RashanGary]

Russ just played himself out of the top spot. It's 12’s to lose.

[texaspackerbacker]

hahahaha At what point in the game did you type that?

[texaspackerbacker]

I just heard something that PISSED ME OFF no end. Fox did a commercial for next week's game portraying it as Aaron Rodgers vs. the GOAT. FUCK THAT!!! And Fuck the shitheads at that network putting out that stupid shit.

No way in hell that Brady comes close to the quality of Aaron Rodgers for a career.

[Upnorth]

So I'm drunk and figured I would say happy canadian thanksgiving!!! Our beer is better and the Vikings can fuck up every time. Assholes.

[Patler]

I just heard something that PISSED ME OFF no end. Fox did a commercial for next week's game portraying it as Aaron Rodgers vs. the GOAT. FUCK THAT!!! And Fuck the shitheads at that network putting out that stupid shit.

No way in hell that Brady comes close to the quality of Aaron Rodgers for a career.

In a big game, I would take Brady in a heartbeat over Rodgers, and it has nothing to do with stats, arm talent, etc.

[Sparkey]

There are many ways to classify GOAT.

Purely on championships, there is no on better than Brady.

Although I wouldn't have expected the GOAT after yelling at his O-line to get their shit together earlier in the game, completely lost his shit regarding what down it was.

[Patler]

There are many ways to classify GOAT.

Purely on championships, there is no on better than Brady.

Although I wouldn't have expected the GOAT after yelling at his O-line to get their shit together earlier in the game, completely lost his shit regarding what down it was.

I have seen a lot of great players get old, many who played too long. One of my saddest moments as a sports fan was watching Willie Mays misplay several routine fly balls in one of his last games, simply because his legs/feet were gone. He was a great defensive outfielder, smooth and graceful in how he played. It was sad watching him play too long, stumbling and tripping.

Nitschke played too long. In some of his last appearances, he couldn't tackle. Again, watching it saddened me.

I'm not sure if Brady has gotten there or not. We will know in the coming weeks.

[Joemailman]

Russ just played himself out of the top spot. It's 12’s to lose.

The marquee games will matter. How Rodgers plays when the go to SF for a national game will be huge.

[run pMc]

hahahaha At what point in the game did you type that?

No idea. Wilson was 15/15 at one point, and was getting pressured frequently.

[texaspackerbacker]

Rodgers is simply better than Brady - past, present, and future. Those shitheads handing Rodgers' GOAT label to Brady should be horse-whipped. If Brady has won some big games, it's because he always had better talent around him.

[Tony Oday]

How good would Brady be without all the cheating?

[Patler]

How good would Brady be without all the cheating?

Probably just as good, which makes all the cheating even more absurd.

[Patler]

Rodgers is simply better than Brady - past, present, and future. Those shitheads handing Rodgers' GOAT label to Brady should be horse-whipped. If Brady has won some big games, it's because he always had better talent around him.

I don't think it is possible to pick a GOAT among NFL qbs. Too many, too close in performance. I won't suggest Brady or Rodgers is the GOAT. That said, if I had to pick between Rodgers and Brady for a single game, I would take Brady over Rodgers; and Favre wouldn't even be on my short list if I had the option of QBs from "all time."

[texaspackerbacker]

Not so. Right now, Rodgers and Mahomes are head and shoulders better than anybody else. Then you have another high level a little below - Watson, Jackson, Dak before the injury, and Wilson and nobody else I can think of on that. Then you have a lot of mediocre QBs below that

If Mahomes plays at the same high level for 12 or 14 more years, then he can maybe be called co-GOAT hahahahaha.

[George Cumby]

In a big game, I would take Brady in a heartbeat over Rodgers, and it has nothing to do with stats, arm talent, etc.

So if it's not what you listed, I assume you mean Brady manages his headspace better in big games?

I'd be curious to see if there's a statistical break-down of that somewhere.

I don't disagree, I just think Rodgers is a better QB, but my sample is biased.

Someone here, I think it was Harv or Joe did a breakdown showing how much better NE's defense has been during Brady's career compared to GB's during Rodgers career. That's kind of put this kind of question into the 'push' category for me.