WHOSE CAREER WOULD YOU RATHER HAVE IF YOU WERE A QB ???

[Bretsky]

What do you think ? MVP's and one time winning the Big Show, or 2 Championships

Both IMO are going to be in the Hall of Fame.

Stroud said in a podcast he's choose Manning's career over Sharon's. Thoughts ?

[Bretsky]

AND SPECIAL ADDITION...............for the KOOL AIDERS>.......in comments you can choose, you'd rather have Jordan Loves career over both of theirs )) But I didn't want to include it in the vote.

[MadtownPacker]

Didn’t even have to read your bullshit. It’s Eli without a doubt. Make the poll with Brady and I will say the same.

Eli beat ‘em both in the worst way.

[Bretsky]

Your post is very interesting Mad; I expected nearly everybody to select Rodgers. I think the poll might suprise you. I hate Sharon, but I think you take my hate to another level.

Erin had multiple MVP's and make it to the NFC title game several times...made playoffs nearly every year

Eli not much success in geting to playoffs, or in the playoffs, except those 2 years when he killed it twice as a champion.

[MadtownPacker]

Cmon, that second post is way dumb. Makes no sense.

Here let me put it like this. Add Brett and I would still say Eli for the same reason. Packers fans remember Favre and Rodgers SB wins but the world remembers Eli’s.

[red]

eli isn't a hall of famer

come on

[MadtownPacker]

We can go even farther with this. Eli still has an big NFL presence. None of the others do after retiring and I doubt Rodgers will either.

[Joemailman]

Rodgers. Only reason Eli has 2 rings is because Giants had great defenses. Both Super Bowls Eli won were low scoring games. I'd rather be the HOF player who won 1 title than the decent player who rode the coattails of others to 2 titles.

[MadtownPacker]

If it’s about stats then your boy Rodgers wins. Thought this was a career/legacy thing. Also Eli stayed with one team which I something I would want if in the NFL. This is about personal satisfaction right B?

Last I checked Woodson and the defense went off that playoffs. Have no doubt without them Erin blows the NFCC vs da bears. Take down your altar that mofo is J-E-T now.

[texaspackerbacker]

Shameful that you would even ask the question, Bretsky.

[Bretsky]

eli isn't a hall of famer

come on

Eli will be in the Hall of Fame for sure. Should he be ? Not performance wise, but the 2nd SB win will land him there

[Bretsky]

If it’s about stats then your boy Rodgers wins. Thought this was a career/legacy thing. Also Eli stayed with one team which I something I would want if in the NFL. This is about personal satisfaction right B?

Last I checked Woodson and the defense went off that playoffs. Have no doubt without them Erin blows the NFCC vs da bears. Take down your altar that mofo is J-E-T now.

I thought this was a great poll. Thrown money out the window; assume you are getting the same. If you are a rookie NFL quarterback whose career would you choose.

The stats...the MVP's.....the playoffs....two teams......One Championship

OR

Solid player...one team.....Two Championships.


You can take the analysis further.

Mad, you and Tex should fight this one out )))

[Bretsky]

Shameful that you would even ask the question, Bretsky.

Tex, can you step back and take your emotions out of this and think deeper on your preference ? No right or wrong answer, but this is not clear cut.

I knew you would go with Rodgers......you crave decency with all Wisconsin sports.

But some, crave championships.

We constantly fight about WI Basektball. I'd rathe suck 8 out of 10 years and win a national champtionship than we good for all ten years and never get to the final 16 (that is what we are)

That is where we always have to agree to disagree

[Bretsky]

Rodgers. Only reason Eli has 2 rings is because Giants had great defenses. Both Super Bowls Eli won were low scoring games. I'd rather be the HOF player who won 1 title than the decent player who rode the coattails of others to 2 titles.

But Eli getting the 2nd ring will get him to the HOF. I agree he's not really good enough; but he'll get there.

there has been a loot of radio debate on that and it's about 50/50. Many at least vote for 2 championships

[MadtownPacker]

Why didn’t you vote on it damn caramel troll.