WHOSE CAREER WOULD YOU RATHER HAVE IF YOU WERE A QB ???

[MadtownPacker]

Shameful that you would even ask the question, Bretsky.

I met him, trust me there is no limit to how low he will go.

[texaspackerbacker]

Tex, can you step back and take your emotions out of this and think deeper on your preference ? No right or wrong answer, but this is not clear cut.

I knew you would go with Rodgers......you crave decency with all Wisconsin sports.

But some, crave championships.

We constantly fight about WI Basektball. I'd rathe suck 8 out of 10 years and win a national champtionship than we good for all ten years and never get to the final 16 (that is what we are)

That is where we always have to agree to disagree

Yeah, this says it all. You emphasize the damn Super Bowl; I say fuck the damn Super Bowl. I say it's all about winning the most games. You don't seem to care unless it's some damn playoff.

And Eli Manning is a piece of crap. If he makes the H of F, it would be a travesty - only because he played in God damned New York and because of his brother's reputation.

The shame of your poll is that you insulted Aaron Rodgers, still the GOAT IMO, and our own, despite some off field crap that some whine about - BFD about that. If you made it a question of Rodgers or Brady, then you'd have a close enough question to have a poll about.

"I crave decency"? That's a laugh. I wouldn't care if the home team - whichever sport - was loaded with scumbags as long as they won the most games.

[Patler]

eli isn't a hall of famer

come on

If Kurt Warner is a HoF'er, Eli Manning certainly is.

[Bretsky]

Yeah, this says it all. You emphasize the damn Super Bowl; I say fuck the damn Super Bowl. I say it's all about winning the most games. You don't seem to care unless it's some damn playoff.

And Eli Manning is a piece of crap. If he makes the H of F, it would be a travesty - only because he played in God damned New York and because of his brother's reputation.

The shame of your poll is that you insulted Aaron Rodgers, still the GOAT IMO, and our own, despite some off field crap that some whine about - BFD about that. If you made it a question of Rodgers or Brady, then you'd have a close enough question to have a poll about.

"I crave decency"? That's a laugh. I wouldn't care if the home team - whichever sport - was loaded with scumbags as long as they won the most games.

I don't think anybody would take Rodgers career over Brady's. That would b a bad poll imo

[Anti-Polar Bear]

Butte might be cocky as fuck, but let’s not forget that Manning reeked of the entitled prick for refusing to play for the Chargerings.

[sharpe1027]

Butte might be cocky as fuck, but let’s not forget that Manning reeked of the entitled prick for refusing to play for the Chargerings.

There's no rule against what he did. It's easy to judge from the couch when it's not your career.

I like him, but I also don't want to judge him too harshly for doing what he thought was best for his career. It proved to be the right decision, afterall.

[ThunderDan]

I voted ARod.

He had the better career. Manning has 1 more ring but only 1 more and he played like horseshit in one of the wins. If it wasn’t for the helmet catch both have 1 ring.

[Joemailman]

If Kurt Warner is a HoF'er, Eli Manning certainly is.

You may be right. I never thought Warner should have been in the HOF. He had 5 outstanding seasons out of 12. People loved the rags to riches story.

[sharpe1027]

You may be right. I never thought Warner should have been in the HOF. He had 5 outstanding seasons out of 12. People loved the rags to riches story.

Trophies for everyone!

The first championship would mean the most to me. Having consistently great teams that I was a big part of would also be important.

Rodgers for me.

[ThunderDan]

You may be right. I never thought Warner should have been in the HOF. He had 5 outstanding seasons out of 12. People loved the rags to riches story.

Kurt Warner is one of my prime examples of players who shouldn’t be in the HOF. He gets injuried and the next guy steps right into the “greatest show on turf” and they don’t miss a beat. Arizona was a bigger accomplishment in my mind.

[Scott Campbell]

Is Rodger’s the better QB? Absolutely.

Giants fans weren’t relieved just to get Eli out of their locker room. For all Aaron’s greatness you don’t see any Packer fan jealousy over the Jets and their fans getting to deal with all the baggage that he brings with him. This week is a prime example.

Most people don’t aspire to have that kind of career legacy.

Ok - I think I just rethought myself into Aaron’s camp. Too late to change my vote. The qualifier in the poll question was “if you were an upcoming NFL QB”. That is a tiny subset of society at large, and those young adults with $$$$ in their eyes probably won’t look any further than Aaron’s superior arm talent.

[bobblehead]

I mean if its etched in stone, I'll take Eli and the extra trophy, but if you are just talking the player its Rodgers in a no brainer. All things equal Rodgers was/is a much better QB.

[MadtownPacker]

Will Rodgers be remembered at all by non Packers fans in 10 years?

[Patler]

Butte might be cocky as fuck, but let’s not forget that Manning reeked of the entitled prick for refusing to play for the Chargerings.

There's no rule against what he did. It's easy to judge from the couch when it's not your career.

I like him, but I also don't want to judge him too harshly for doing what he thought was best for his career. It proved to be the right decision, afterall.

Agreed. I don't see what Manning did as anymore "prickish" than opting for free agency when your contract expires. If you don't want to play for the team that holds your rights, get out whenever you can.

John Elway was drafted by the Colts and refused to play for them, saying he would play pro baseball instead. Most people assumed it was an idle threat, but he had played baseball at Stanford too, and had been drafted by the Yankees. I believe he played a minor league season for them. The Colts and Elway haggled a long time before the Colts traded his rights to the Broncos.

Bruce Clark refused to play for Green Bay. Green Bay refused to trade his rights, so he went to Canada. Lots of NBA and NHL draftees have forced trades.

[Patler]

I would take Rodgers' career to Manning's career by a current factor of 263,000,000 for Rodgers' career to 252,000,000 for Manning's career.