OFFICIAL BRETT THE LIVING LEGEND THREAD

[channtheman]

This thread is just supposed to be funny. Chill out Woodbuck, don't get it removed from packerrats history.

[Upnorth]

So on a football related note Favre was one hell of a QB. Let's pretend were hall of fame voters for a moment and forget his off field antics. Keeping this in mind is he top 10 ever? To me he easily was during the regular season, however had a few disheartening gaffs in the post season. I put Starr, Montana and Marino as no brainers above him. I also think of current players Brady and .anning are better. Who else do yÓu think of the modern era qbs is better than Favre?

[Scott Campbell]

So on a football related note Favre was one hell of a QB. Let's pretend were hall of fame voters for a moment and forget his off field antics. Keeping this in mind is he top 10 ever? To me he easily was during the regular season, however had a few disheartening gaffs in the post season. I put Starr, Montana and Marino as no brainers above him. I also think of current players Brady and .anning are better. Who else do yÓu think of the modern era qbs is better than Favre?

Rodgers. Eli. Brees. Elway.


People won't ever completely forget the off field antics. Favre's lasting legacy will be his penis, and national ridicule.

[Brando19]

Tebow.

[Pugger]

This thread is just supposed to be funny. Chill out Woodbuck, don't get it removed from packerrats history.

If you don't like the thread, Woodbuck, why are you continuing to read and respond to it???

[Pugger]

So on a football related note Favre was one hell of a QB. Let's pretend were hall of fame voters for a moment and forget his off field antics. Keeping this in mind is he top 10 ever? To me he easily was during the regular season, however had a few disheartening gaffs in the post season. I put Starr, Montana and Marino as no brainers above him. I also think of current players Brady and .anning are better. Who else do yÓu think of the modern era qbs is better than Favre?

He was a great QB but his Achille's heel was he had brain farts in big games. More often than not he'd turn the ball over at the absolute worst possible moment. He was a warrior and helped the Pack return to glory after 20+ years of misery. I'd put him in the top 10 in the league, sure. But not above Starr, Graham, Marino, Peyton, Young, Unitas, Brady and Montana.

[Pugger]

Rodgers. Eli. Brees. Elway.


People won't ever completely forget the off field antics. Favre's lasting legacy will be his penis, and national ridicule.

It's WAY to early to include Brees and Rodgers in the top 10 in NFL history.

[Pugger]

Tebow.

You're funny!

[Scott Campbell]

It's WAY to early to include Brees and Rodgers in the top 10 in NFL history.

Well, that wasn't the question.

[MadtownPacker]

This thread is just supposed to be funny. Chill out Woodbuck, don't get it removed from packerrats history.

This thread is suppose to contain all the Favre talk not be scott and woodys battles ground.

Officially asking ScottCampbell and Woody to take there personal battle to the GC or they will get removed from PackerRats present.

[MadtownPacker]

But not above Starr, Graham, Marino, Peyton, Young, Unitas, Brady and Montana.

I imagine you are old enough to have seen all these QBs but I am only old enough to have seen half of them play. You really believe Peyton has been better? More efficient? Maybe but hardly what I would call clutch based on seeing several of his meltdowns in big games. Plus he is boring as hell to watch. Marino never won a SB and he had lots of shots so I cant agree with that. Young would be about equal IMO except that he never could beat the Favre led Packers other than TO's catch game which Jerry Rice had already fumbled away.

[Scott Campbell]

This thread is suppose to contain all the Favre talk not be scott and woodys battles ground.

Officially asking ScottCampbell and Woody to take there personal battle to the GC or they will get removed from PackerRats present.

Awesome.

Order has been restored in our beautiful thread.

[swede]

Isn't Brett Favre that creepy guy that used to play for us until he went to New York and acted like a pervert towards all kinds of young ladies by texting pictures of his dongus or trying to molest them when they were hired to simply give a therapeutic massage, thus shaming himself, betraying his family, and alienating all but the most retarded die-hard Favre fans?

What about him?

[pbmax]

Isn't Brett Favre that creepy guy that used to play for us until he went to New York and acted like a pervert towards all kinds of young ladies by texting pictures of his dongus or trying to molest them when they were hired to simply give a therapeutic massage, thus shaming himself, betraying his family, and alienating all but the most retarded die-hard Favre fans?

What about him?

He's selling Sham Wow and Rent A Center on TV.

[Scott Campbell]

Good posts everybody!