LeRoy: Brett Better Than Aaron

[sharpe1027]

Butler in in the entertainment business. Getting noticed generally = good for business.

[Tarlam!]

These "who was better?" arguments in general (Montana-Elway? Elway-Marino? et al) have always seemes pretty pointless to me and especially so in this case.

With this I agree.[...] The comparison about "who is better" is for pundits and fans and completely irrelevant.

It's not pointless to me, nor is it irrelevant. I enjoy the debate about it, because lots of additional info comes to light. Fans and pundits get a kick out of it. The debate between Rodgers and the other guy is only as emotional as it is because one of them played for an NFCN rival with the intention of sticking it to the upper management of the Packers. If not for that, I assume the discussion would be a downright love fest. Alas.

Anyone else hear Marshall Faulk say Aaron Rodgers is not a top 5 or elite level QB...because "Matt Flynn did what Aaron Rodgers can do"

Was he being sarcastic??

[Bossman641]

Anyone else hear Marshall Faulk say Aaron Rodgers is not a top 5 or elite level QB...because "Matt Flynn did what Aaron Rodgers can do"

Seriously?

[Pugger]

Well, no matter what Favre did in his career by 2007 he just wasn't going to work out for us. You can't have your starting QB struggle in the cold when your team is in Wisconsin. This is most likely why MM and company were more than ready to give the reigns to Airin' and didn't think twice about trading Favre to NY.

[Smidgeon]

say what? Favre never had offensive weapons like AR has...just say'n. lets be real. Farve had some good weapons, but he also made some crappy guys look really good, and never an offense like we have today.

He had some good weapons over the years...but never the talent that AR currently has as a whole. Not even close.

again comparing different era's in football is using faulty logic. the game is way different today than it was when Favre was in his prime. The NFL has slowly changed the game to exploit the popularity of the most popular players in the NFL...which are QB's. It's not much of an accident there are so many high flying offense in this yr's playoffs and such bad defenses.

So help me out here. How are your statements not comparing eras?

[Fritz]

Should we be accounting for penis size in this comparison?

[jdrats]

Should we be accounting for penis size in this comparison?

By what standard? Megapixels?

[Brando19]

why is everyone here so dumb when it comes to Favre?

Is it not possible to think that Butler thought AR was the best QB in the division in 2009 when Favre was at the end of his career and AR was just coming into his own? Thats a far cry from being the best overall in his mind? yeah great find.....

Yeah, man...you're real cool. Dumb? It's my opinion...asshole.

[MJZiggy]

Well, no matter what Favre did in his career by 2007 he just wasn't going to work out for us. You can't have your starting QB struggle in the cold when your team is in Wisconsin. This is most likely why MM and company were more than ready to give the reigns to Airin' and didn't think twice about trading Favre to NY.

I believe I once heard that the playoff loss in the cold was a reason M3 was ready to move on.

[mmmdk]

I believe I once heard that the playoff loss in the cold was a reason M3 was ready to move on.

Spot on!

[denverYooper]

I believe I once heard that the playoff loss in the cold was a reason M3 was ready to move on.

He wasn't the only one.

[MJZiggy]

He wasn't the only one.

You're right. TT was ready as well.

[Packers4Glory]

Yeah, man...you're real cool. Dumb? It's my opinion...asshole.

sorry dickweed, but the 2 statements were totally unrelated. So, yes, your opinion is dumb.

[mraynrand]

ya kinda knew this thread wasn't going to end well....

[MJZiggy]

ya kinda knew this thread wasn't going to end well....

Yeah, but kudos on seeing the drain swirling so quickly.