Is Packers' McCarthy the NFL's best coach?

[SnakeLH2006]

http://www.620wtmj.com/sports/green-bay-packers/201607401.html

__________________________________________________ _______

LOLLOLOOLOOLOLOLOLOLOLLOLOLOLOOOOLLLLLLOOLOLLLL.

He's ok. But he's too complacent with passing non-stop (granted Arod is the best QB right now)...and not establishing the run...and really makes some bonehead playcalls given statistics...I mean how many times will he run on 3rd and 1 given our abysmal running game to get that 1st down. I don't mind MM as a coach (I'm not bashing him really...but there's a few coaches I'd rather have) but would take Belichek, Fox, or any of the Harbaugh brothers, or even Cowher or a few NFL coaches in broadcasting in a nano-second....Just saying.......and oh yeah..he praises that douchebag JerkMichael Finley alllll the time...that guy is a huge waste. Show some balls and bench his cheating lying thug punkass. Snake met that thug once and knows many stories bout that scumbag....and many more do now...and they work with him EVERY day and know he's a bitch...and see him underperform and show up late...and still play him and pay him..he still makes $8.5 million...sickening..I'm just looking at on the field production though..and he sucks vs. his contract.

[Pugger]

I realize you are no fan and he isn't perfect by any means but MM is regarded as a top 10 head coach by most folks. Belichick is #1.

http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap1000000157180/article/bill-belichick-tom-coughlin-sit-atop-current-nfl-coach-rankings

http://www.theepochtimes.com/n2/sports/best-current-nfl-coaches-339516.html

http://www.nfl.com/photoessays/09000d5d82849b56#photo=1

http://www.athlonsports.com/nfl/ranking-nfls-top-10-head-coaches-2012

http://espn.go.com/blog/afceast/post/_/id/27641/power-rankings-top-10-nfl-head-coaches

[King Friday]

Can't see McCarthy as a top 5 coach. He has some limitations. He's a good coach, but I can't put him in the elite class at this point, and he needs to produce several more years of consistent 12 win seasons with an MVP caliber QB to prove himself. Hell, Mike Sherman could win 10-12 games with Favre.

[gbgary]

coach? got to be one of the best but his play-calling has always been an issue.

[Mazzin]

I agree with Gary. The play calling leaves much to be desired, but as far as him and his staff getting all they can out of their young players. Phenominal

[woodbuck27]

Mike McCarthy... The NFL's Best Head Coach?

Best! Best!! Best!!! Echo ....... No! NO!! NO!!!

Hell no! When I watch Mike McCarthy in any big game I see:



A deer in the headlights.

Next question.

[pbmax]

Belichick I understand. Even get Harbaugh love. But John Fox? Really?

One losing Super Bowl appearance in 20 years plus Elway for a year in the AFC West?

He is Lovie Smith with a better QB.

[Bretsky]

Belichick I understand. Even get Harbaugh love. But John Fox? Really?

One losing Super Bowl appearance in 20 years plus Elway for a year in the AFC West?

He is Lovie Smith with a better QB.

IMO John Fox is way better than Lovie. He's a great communcator and leader. I'd take MM over Fox fwiw.

IMO our guy is a very solid coach. Very good.....certainly not elite. Easily top 10....maybe around the 5 area for the optimiists and around the 10 area for the pessimists.

[Bretsky]

I must admit I really do like Adam Schein....but for some of the same reasons I like Chuckie...I find him very entertaining.
However, he is the ultimate Packer Homer.

Listening to him the last years, he has MM in for weekly talks all the tiem and kisses some serious ass.

He has also predicted Green Bay would win the last two Super Bowls.....and kind of called the run they had the year they did win it.

[Bretsky]

I'm not a buyer into Andy Reid anymore; I need to see him do something in KC before setting him in thetop 10
I must life Jeff Fischer more than most......he'd be in that range.
I also like Pete Carroll more than most...I think he's dam good as well
I also like Sean Payton more than most...he's in that range as well

Guys like Mike Tomlin, MM, both Harbarughs, Sean Payston......at this point to me they all fall in a similar range

There is only one Hoody Genius, and until somebody wins their 2nd Big Show Coughlin deserves the 2 spot

[pbmax]

I'm not a buyer into Andy Reid anymore; I need to see him do something in KC before setting him in thetop 10
I must life Jeff Fischer more than most......he'd be in that range.
I also like Pete Carroll more than most...I think he's dam good as well
I also like Sean Payton more than most...he's in that range as well

Guys like Mike Tomlin, MM, both Harbarughs, Sean Payston......at this point to me they all fall in a similar range

There is only one Hoody Genius, and until somebody wins their 2nd Big Show Coughlin deserves the 2 spot

I am with you on Andy, though I think he is an excellent coach, he might be burned out. Not as high on Fisher or Carroll. Like Payton and Tomlin.

Also, you should start pestering Rastak to come in for the draft. Time is running out.

[Mazzin]

Pete Carrol..maybe, but Fisher? Come on what has he done?

[red]

no to m3, not even close

he has no ability what so ever at adjusting during a game, and IMO, thats a pretty big part of coaching

[woodbuck27]

Looking at the numbers for Mike McCarthy Vs Bill Belichick and Tom Coughlin.

I have to give this to Mike McCarthy:



That's my best tuxedo.

I don't get it why people put the hate on Pete Carroll. Everytime I see that man on NFL Access he's more impressive.

Tom Coughlin...yaa gotta love that guy. He's a tough little Irishman, with a good heart down deep. He's a fricken hard working HC like Hoody.

Woohahh. I've likely got that wrong.

Who works harder than Bill Belichick?

[Bretsky]

It was not fair that Hoddy Coach Genius was able to hire Hoody Offensive Coordinator Genius last year

That would be like Ted Thompson hiring the best former GM out there who has plenty of game lift in Scott Pioli.........hmmmmmmmmmmmm