OFFICIAL BRETT THE LIVING LEGEND THREAD

[Fritz]

Sure, I remember the good times, early on. But that was before he gained all that weight and started staying in the basement with his buddies, drinking beer, never showering. And then he'd just lay there at night, not even touching me. And that's why it bothered me so when I'd catch him looking at others. I could see the lust in his eyes, but when I offered myself to him, he said he wasn't sure he wanted me any more. It was so humiliating! And then he said he was leaving. And I was glad. But scared, too. And after that, when he said he wasn't sure he wanted to leave, I had such...such....mixed feelings. But I told him he had to make up his mind. And he seemed insulted by that. I became so confused.

But yes, I remember the good times. The way he'd lift up his leg and fart, then laugh - oh, his eyes! And the passes he'd make. So thrilling. He was so child-like in his love.

Yes, I remember those days. Sigh.

[packerbacker1234]

My take on Brett without an apology

Great QB who played his way, was fun to watch and had a lot of success on the field. I don't think he's as important as many people credited to him so I do still discuss that. It's really not even a knock on him, but rather people giving him credit that was impossible for a person to live up to. Top 3 all time packer QB. But, he became such a harmful, destructive, nasty A-wipe late in his career and did so many shitty things, I don't care to ever see him in Lambeau again, for any reason.



My take on Brett with an apology for what happened

Same as the last except I'll be happy to cheer for him if he comes back and I'll forget about all the drama. He's human just like us. But human beings should feel bad when they screw up and they should apologize. He does this and it doesn't make him a better QB in my eyes, but I do think he was great and I'll be able to appreciate it way more.



Back to the messy Divorce analogy, I don't know if it's that bad. It's more like being associated with a person who you found out was selfish and nasty and now don't want much to do with them. Sadly, right now, pre-apology, that's a big part of his legacy. I know some would like that to go away, but only Favre can make that happen and only if he's man enough. Picturing him on Greta Van Sustren, I odn't know if he is.

His legacy is just fine, even if you count all the stuff.

What Favre will be remembered for:

- Toughest QB to ever play the game. The start streak is incredible, especially considering the injuries he played through and how he seemed to perform better when he was hurt.
- Greatest statistical QB of all time. Takes over that legacy from Marino, who become the greatest statistical QB to never win a ring now.
- Will always be remembered for the Will He Wont He, and how he almost ended his career on top. Almost.
- The one player you always knew loved this game on the field. His child like enthusiam in every big moment, after every TD, it's not something we are accustomed to from any other player.

In GB we may remember him for some other things, but I think Nation wide above sums it up. Tough as hell, amazing stats and longevity, will he wont he, love of the game.

Oh, and of course "risk taker".

[Scott Campbell]

Favre had a great legacy, and now it's crap. Even today he's still the butt of all the late night jokes.

Over time people may mellow and forget what a douchebag he is. But that assumes that he stops being a douchebag at some point.

[Scott Campbell]

Ted sure emerged from this smelling like a rose.

[TravisWilliams23]

This is great! Can I share it with others?

"legend write their own stories, my Brett our Favre."
Sure Pugger, have fun with it.

[pbmax]

I am right, you are wrong.
No, I am right, YOU are wrong.

I am a cold eyed observer of fact. You are a hater.
I am a student of history, you are an emotional and needy fan-person.

We are both a little right, but your emotional outbursts betray your flaws.
We are both a little right, but secretly, I think you are full of baloney.

Admit it, you still love him.
Admit it, you've fallen for the new guy.

I may have said some things out of haste, but your statements were indications of a blight on your soul.
I may have predicted some things that didn't happen, but you are even more clueless.

Its clear this thread has come to the end of its useful life. When will you stop posting?
Its clear this thread has come to the end of its useful life. I will stop posting after one more passive aggressive swipe at my target and his supporters.

Why are you so immature and bitter? Cannot you accept your happy fate?
Why are you so immature and bitter? Cannot you admit you were wrong?

When are you going to grow up?
When are YOU going to grow up?

I will do so only after you modify your behavior in accordance with my judgment.
I will do so only after you modify your behavior to align better with my expectations.

One side of the coin
The other side of the coin.

[RashanGary]

Brett was going to be remembered as a good, honest, genuine guy who was great at football. Now he'll be remembered as a wife cheating, dishonest, phony and a dirty creeper who was great at football.

The football stays the same. Believe it or not, there is more to the people we cheer for than what they do on the field. Brett will be remembered as much for what he did off of it. Jen Sterger, the massage therapists, dragging his team through bizarre, dishonest BS to get what he wanted only to get what he didn't want, and his old team winning the SB as soon as he left town.

If you believe in justice, he's being remembered for who he is. If you believe in Favre, he should be remembered for what he wants you to remember him for. Do we stand by our virtues or our idol? where does our allegiance lie? That's the question.

[mraynrand]

I am right, you are wrong.
No, I am right, YOU are wrong.

I am a cold eyed observer of fact. You are a hater.
I am a student of history, you are an emotional and needy fan-person.

We are both a little right, but your emotional outbursts betray your flaws.
We are both a little right, but secretly, I think you are full of baloney.

Admit it, you still love him.
Admit it, you've fallen for the new guy.

I may have said some things out of haste, but your statements were indications of a blight on your soul.
I may have predicted some things that didn't happen, but you are even more clueless.

Its clear this thread has come to the end of its useful life. When will you stop posting?
Its clear this thread has come to the end of its useful life. I will stop posting after one more passive aggressive swipe at my target and his supporters.

Why are you so immature and bitter? Cannot you accept your happy fate?
Why are you so immature and bitter? Cannot you admit you were wrong?

When are you going to grow up?
When are YOU going to grow up?

I will do so only after you modify your behavior in accordance with my judgment.
I will do so only after you modify your behavior to align better with my expectations.

One side of the coin
The other side of the coin.

This is a great post. No, no wait, it is an awful post!

[LP]

Berts career ended with the Green Bay Packers winning the Super Bowl!

That's just how he wanted it, right?

[Guiness]

Berts career ended with the Green Bay Packers winning the Super Bowl!

That's just how he wanted it, right?

[RashanGary]

Berts career ended with the Green Bay Packers winning the Super Bowl!

That's just how he wanted it, right?

True and you can ask anyone in this thread, the Packers wouldn't have even been in the playoffs if not for Favre, so surely we can't blame him for anything. Brett carried the franchise out of a 15 year slump. What a hero.

[GrnBay007]

Brett was going to be remembered as a good, honest, genuine guy who was great at football.

^^^^^THAT ended for many of you when he joined another team. Jen Sterger deal was just icing on the cake...a gift with perfect timing. If Favre was still a Packer and playing great football this board would have been full of posts about what a whore and gold digger she is. Sorry but I don't doubt that one bit.

[channtheman]

^^^^^THAT ended for many of you when he joined another team. Jen Sterger deal was just icing on the cake...a gift with perfect timing. If Favre was still a Packer and playing great football this board would have been full of posts about what a whore and gold digger she is. Sorry but I don't doubt that one bit.

I disagree. Favre was always chasing women, he just didn't make it so public or let it get out like he did with Jenn Sterger. With the internet nowadays, Favre should have known better than to send dick pix and booty call phone messages to another phone where he then has no control over where they go. Now, if he was still a Packer would we ignore it? Possibly.

[Bossman641]

When Favre left the Packers the media referred to the split as that similar to a messy divorce. I believed it then, but as time has gone by the similarities are unreal.

There are some that are really OK with the split. They are secure with who they are (what they have in a QB) and just let the past die.

There are some that are unhappy with the split and the way things went down but are fine just talking facts and not letting emotions get in the way.

Then there are those that are downright bitter about the split. It's all the "ex's" fault and "they" did NOTHING wrong. They are quiet and out of site when the "ex" seems to be doing well, but holy bejesus when the "ex" messes up in any way shape or form, they are the first to jump on and give them hell. They tend to brag about how much better they are without the "ex" and they make a fool of themselves trying to make the "ex" look bad. Sometimes they even try to re-write history to prove their point.

For those in the last category, let it go! He is a BIG part of Packer history and as a Packer fan you should be proud of that history....ALL of it. Just like the divorce....you may not be happy with the ending, but surely at some point there was something there that drew you to that person and for some moment in time they made you happy. Don't let the bitterness overshadow the happy times!

I know you are a whole lot smarter than this. Wasn't the same exact thing true for the Favre supporters? Constantly putting down TT and saying what a mistake he made, pointing out how Rodgers would never be as good as Favre. There were a group of posters here who spent 95% of their time discussing Favre and only 5% the Packers.

[HarveyWallbangers]

Rodgers is good. Thanks for the championship team THANKSTED! You made the right move--despite being mocked and ridiculed for three years running. Game over. We win. Bert loses.