OFFICIAL BRETT THE LIVING LEGEND THREAD

[Deputy Nutz]

Call it whatever you will, I remember Packer fans being pretty excited when Favre came back every season, I remember his teammates being excited when he came back for another season. when he came back for 2007 he didn't leave much of a gap, he made the decision pretty early. I might be wrong about that but I thought it was long before the draft.

[woodbuck27]

You missed the tiny little fact that he RETIRED and unretired, retired unretired and held a franchise hostage! Did you forget that? In you brain tumor induced tirades on this site did you ever see that he did that or is it revisionist history here? F you could get a staff job with Obama.

"In you brain tumor induced tirades on this site did you ever see that he did that or is it revisionist history here? F you could get a staff job with Obama." Tony Oday

The above extablishes your credibility as a member here that has a clue regarding 'the TRUTH'!?

Nope. You failed yourself miserably in the above false judgements and in terms of your conduct and manners.

Your out to lunch Tony Oday. You beat yourself. The weird thing here is that 'the usual suspects' will applaud you.

[Tony Oday]

Will he retire, wont he retire, will he retire, wont he retire...Will he text wont he text will he text wont he text? Will he throw a pick that is always a yes.

[woodbuck27]

I am wrong he didnt actually retire every time. He did hold the Pack hostage for the last three years of his career here with Favre watch.

Bullshit !

Favre always said the same thing at the end of his last few seasons as a Packer. Re: returning.

As the season ended he said he wasn't sure he would be back but felt he could still contribute.. That he would have to see if 'in fact' the Packer organization wanted him back.

[woodbuck27]

Will he retire, wont he retire, will he retire, wont he retire...Will he text wont he text will he text wont he text? Will he throw a pick that is always a yes.

WOW! I get it.

Your an angry man. Lie down. Take a break.

[Tony Oday]

Your right Favre always said he would come back right away ESPN was just looking for ratings and faked it all.

[Tony Oday]

[MadtownPacker]

Tony, there was no issue until you made it personal. I'm gonna to shut you down for the day until you cool off. You will be active again tomorrow.

[woodbuck27]

Well Woodbuck let's get to the TRUTH then. I will start with a list of statements and we will decide if they are true or false. Maybe that way we can have some ground rules to argue by.

True or False (My answers in brackets):
1. BF was the starting QB for the Packers for the 2007 NFC Championship game. (True)
2. BF retired from the NFL. (True)
3. The Packers stated that ARod was their starting QB for the 2008 season. (True)
4. BF called the Packers and said he wanted to unretire. (True)
5. MM and TT were ready to fly to MS to meet with BF regarding his position with the Packers. (True)
6. BF called TT and said he was going to stay retired. (True)
7. BF calls the Packers and says he wants to play. (True)
8. MM tells BF that he has to compete for the starting QB position. (True)

Let's start with that and see what we come up with.

This true and fase post though I appreciate the effort put forth in it is moot and off topic.

ThunderDan...Focus please on the status of Brett Favre Vs TT and MM... 'in terms of continued bad feeling' or NOT.

I assure you. To go on trying to establish that Favre has such bad feelings is a losing position ThunderDan. I'll advise you further.

Maybe? consider this Thunderdan.

It's not self gratifying when I certainly know I can back myself up. It might just be easier for you to save face by standing down. Your position 'will lose' for you.

I've been a teacher most of my life. A good teacher ensures that the student puts in the necessary effort towords arriving at the correct answer / response / TRUTH. The window of time to arrive at that TRUTH is from AQugust 2008 untill well today. fill your boots.

Find the TRUTH and don't expect me to spoon feed you that TRUTH. Are you familiar at all with martial arts? My way and methods are much derived from that.

I won't give to you what I worked so hard to find.

[MadtownPacker]

Let's make sure to keep our argument about the topic and not make it personal.

[woodbuck27]

Let's make sure to keep our argument about the topic and not make it personal.

Correct Mad.

It serves no logical purpose not to simply question the post whenever another member feels that's relevant. Ignorance may warrant a return post that only demonstrates a mutual disrespect and results in a 'no win' situation. A sad outcome. We deserve more from one another as members here.

To attack the poster with 'flaming language and accusations that cannot be justified': with poor manners.

Is certainly unacceptable.

[MadtownPacker]

Correct Mad.

It serves no logical purpose not to simply question the post whenever another member feels that's relevant. Ignorance may warrant a return post that only demonstrates a mutual disrespect and results in a 'no win' situation. A sad outcome. We deserve more from one another as members here.

To attack the poster with 'flaming language and accusations that cannot be justified': with poor manners.

Is certainly unacceptable.

Youre right its not acceptable so before you declare yourself a moral authority think about when you start jumping down on someones throat for having any opinion that differs from yours.

[woodbuck27]

To change the quote from Hamlet - the man doth protests too much - especially when it comes to Favre. Good lord, if some of us have no use for our previous QB why does that bother you so much??? You are still a fan. Bully for you. Don't preach to us if we feel differently.

The Packers offered an olive branch. Let's see how #4 responds.

Did the Packers offer 'an olive branch'? Has that offer been made concretely?

I do not see it that way Pugger.

[ThunderDan]

It wasn't Ted Thompson's place to try and control Brett Favre's life; decisions ' in anything ' football.

Sorry, woodbuck but that highlighted statement is a complete and utter bold faced lie!

As the GM of the GB Packers, TT's job was to "control" all of the players under contract with the GB Packers.

If TT would have released BF with no compensation I would have been on board with demanding TT's resignation.

The job of the GM is to make their team as competitive as possible in the NFL and releasing players for no compensation and letting them go to a divisional foe is complete mismanagement by a GM.

[ThunderDan]

After Favre left the NY Jets. and PLEASE.... The Jets didn't dump Favre as many of you have decided to believe.

Now let's see the real TRUTH that woodbuck claims.

BF retired from the Jets. He then told Mike Tannenbaum that he wanted his release from the Jets assuring the GM that he was done playing in the NFL. Tannenbaum said NO. Then Bus Cook got into the act again saying BF wasn't going to play again and wanted his release from the Jets. This time Mike Tannenbaum did.

After BF got his release he started talking with the Vikings saying he wanted to stick it to TT and Packers.