Is Aaron Rodgers even good anymore?

[beveaux1]

I've had the opportunity to look at 4 or 5 games of all 22(coaches film) and I've seen the same things that Ben Fennell has seen.

There are definitely open receivers. Rodgers is sometimes antsy in the pocket, bailing quickly even when protection is holding up.

But, if you look at the film and try to see the routes that Rodgers' prefers. They are not usually open. A WR might break open over the middle,
but the sideline route and the RB in the flat are not open. Some of the time, that's when he throws the post to a doubled WR, probably in hopes of getting a flag.

At this point in his career, Rodgers is not going to change where he looks to throw. He will not give up an interception in a contested game. The best chance for
this offense to show marked improvement is to get another "sudden" WR. One that quickly gets open so that Rodgers can hit his preferred throws.

That means waiting until next year.

[texaspackerbacker]

What I like most about Tex is that he is always willing to respectfully consider contrary opinions.

God damned media shitheads don't deserve ...

PB: The rest you can take to FYI

[Smidgeon]

He used to be better at the middle stuff, didn't he?

[George Cumby]

HE HAS A BONER FOR RODGERS THAT JUST WONT QUIT!

I WAS ADDICTED TO DICK! I! WAS! ADDICTED! TO! DICK!

[ThunderDan]

God damned media shitheads don't deserve to live much less be considered credible.

Once again showing your horrible self. It is really sad.

You really are a snowflake if you can’t hear what is actually happening on the field. The guy has studied the film from all of our games. Posters in the game day thread comment over and over that guys are open over the middle and Rodgers won’t throw it. Game stats show that our Oline is much better than you give it credit for and more credit that I give it also.

[George Cumby]

God damned media shitheads don't deserve ...

Because the violent suppression of those who express opinions different from ones own in no way...

PB: Please finish your thought in FYI

[gbgary]

God damned media shitheads don't deserve to live much less be considered credible.

the media didn't create those stats...rodgers did. lol

[gbgary]

His cap hit goes from 13.5% to 15.5%, which isn't awful.

I agree with you that Rodgers isn't adapting his game to the new offense and the reports of him not pulling the trigger on open WRs is coming from more and more sources. I hope he can fix himself, because at this point, he's the only one that can do it.

anything over 11% is bad. anything over 12 is awful. anything over 13 is god awful. 15% is ridiculous. only one qb has ever won a SB over 13...steve young...the first year of the cap. only 4 qb's had ever won with 11+%. peyton, eli, young, and brady. last year brady was 12.4 (which is unusually high for him).

[beveaux1]

He used to be better at the middle stuff, didn't he?

He’s always thrown it if the receiver is WIDE open. Very seldom with a safety bearing down or with a CB within a step of the WR.

[texaspackerbacker]

Once again showing your horrible self. It is really sad.

You really are a snowflake if you can’t hear what is actually happening on the field. The guy has studied the film from all of our games. Posters in the game day thread comment over and over that guys are open over the middle and Rodgers won’t throw it. Game stats show that our Oline is much better than you give it credit for and more credit that I give it also.

You God damned imbecilic ingrate. Other QBs do what stupid fools wish for - throw it quick into traffic and throw interceptions and give away games. I'll take a QB who does not do that any day. If you think differently, you are as much of an idiot as your posts make you seem.

[texaspackerbacker]

Because the violent suppression of those who express opinions different from ones own in no way resembles fascism.

Why is not this piece of shit banned or at least threatened for politics - not to mention idiocy? If you have the balls, take your shit to FYI.

[ThunderDan]

You God damned imbecilic ingrate. Other QBs do what stupid fools wish for - throw it quick into traffic and throw interceptions and give away games. I'll take a QB who does not do that any day. If you think differently, you are as much of an idiot as your posts make you seem.

Who is throwing INTs in the NFL this year? Winston, Mayfield, Darold, Rivers, Prescott. A bunch of QBs who are mostly on bad teams that need to press to try and win games

Who isn’t throwing INTs? Bree’s, Brady, Cousins, Mahommes, Jackson, Rodgers, Wentz.

Why don’t you know the facts first before your run your mouth like an idiot. You can’t even admit to the truth. ARod is having a below average year for him and a very average year for an NFL QB.

[George Cumby]

Why is not this piece of shit banned or at least threatened for politics - not to mention idiocy? If you have the balls, take your shit to FYI.

First point please take to Interpol.

Second point ot FYI.

[red]

I've had the opportunity to look at 4 or 5 games of all 22(coaches film) and I've seen the same things that Ben Fennell has seen.

There are definitely open receivers. Rodgers is sometimes antsy in the pocket, bailing quickly even when protection is holding up.

But, if you look at the film and try to see the routes that Rodgers' prefers. They are not usually open. A WR might break open over the middle,
but the sideline route and the RB in the flat are not open. Some of the time, that's when he throws the post to a doubled WR, probably in hopes of getting a flag.

At this point in his career, Rodgers is not going to change where he looks to throw. He will not give up an interception in a contested game. The best chance for
this offense to show marked improvement is to get another "sudden" WR. One that quickly gets open so that Rodgers can hit his preferred throws.

That means waiting until next year.

this has been going on for years, the commentators have just been covering up for him . they would show guys making a break and getting a step on a guy, then tells us that the guy wasn't open

this is why we needed to get rid of fat mike years ago. he allowed all this to happen, he let rodgers do whatever he wanted and continue to get away with not throwing to the open guys for short to mid yardage

a-rods offense isn't good enough, and at this point, i don't think he's going to give up his power to do whatever he wants. somehow, someway, someone has to try and convince him that his way sucks

but like we saw with his own family, if anyone does anything other then blow rose smelling smoke up his ass, he'll disown them

the people in charge (murphy), should have seen this and traded him last offseason instead of re signing him

[red]

He used to be better at the middle stuff, didn't he?

i remember our bread and butter was the slant